Black Friday Sale — $20 off selected themes

Shop all themes
PremiumPress
← Back to the blog

Gumroad Alternatives in 2026: Fees Compared for Payhip, Lemon Squeezy, Sellfy and WordPress

By Mark Fail ·

Gumroad Alternatives in 2026: Fees Compared for Payhip, Lemon Squeezy, Sellfy and WordPress

Gumroad's pricing page lists one rate today. You pay 10% plus $0.50 on every sale you bring in yourself, and 30% when a buyer finds you through its Discover marketplace. Its help centre adds that card processing of 2.9% plus $0.30 sits on top of the 10%. On a $20 ebook that's $3.38 gone before any tax, so you keep $16.62.

That fee is why most people start looking around. Sell 500 copies of that ebook and Gumroad's own cut is $1,250.

We opened every option below on 10 October 2026 and read the fees on each company's own pricing page. Three are hosted platforms, one is a free WordPress plugin, and one is our own theme for a store you run yourself. Card processing from Stripe or PayPal is extra on all of them unless we say it's included.

At a glance

OptionPriceFee per saleSales taxOwn domainBest for
Gumroad (for reference)No monthly fee10% + $0.50, or 30% via DiscoverGumroad files itYes-
PayhipFree, $29 or $99 a month5%, 2% or 0%Payhip files EU and UK VATYesStarting with no monthly bill
Lemon SqueezyNo monthly fee5% + $0.50Lemon Squeezy files itYesSoftware with licence keys
SellfyFrom $22 a month, billed yearly0%Tax settings, you fileYesSteady sales under $10k a year
WordPress pluginsFree plugin + hosting3% on the free versionYou fileYesA WordPress site you already have
PremiumPress Digital Download$99 one-time + hosting0% to usYou set rates and fileYesA whole store on your own site

Payhip

Payhip pricing page showing the Free Forever, Plus and Pro plans with their transaction fees

Payhip is the closest thing to Gumroad with half the fee. You upload a file, set a price and share a link, and Payhip hosts the product page and the checkout. Its Free Forever plan costs $0 a month with a 5% transaction fee. Plus is $29 a month with 2%, and Pro is $99 a month with no transaction fee. PayPal and Stripe still charge their standard rates on every plan.

The pricing page says all three plans have the same features, with unlimited products and unlimited revenue. So the free plan already includes the store builder, coupons and licence keys, which you can upload yourself or have Payhip generate. Payhip says it deposits your money straight after each transaction, so there's no payout day to wait for.

Tax is partly handled. Payhip says it collects and remits EU and UK VAT on digital sales for you, and acts as a marketplace facilitator for US and Canadian sales tax. Any other tax you set up yourself, and Payhip sends that money to you to report.

Pros

  • Half of Gumroad's percentage on the free plan, and no $0.50 per sale
  • Every feature on every plan, licence keys included
  • EU and UK VAT filed for you

Cons

  • Dropping to 2% or 0% means $29 or $99 every month
  • Stripe and PayPal fees come on top of Payhip's fee
  • Taxes outside the EU, UK, US and Canada are yours to report
Visit Site

Lemon Squeezy

Lemon Squeezy pricing page with a banner about its 2026 Stripe Managed Payments update

Lemon Squeezy charges 5% plus $0.50 per transaction and no monthly fee. Like Gumroad it is the merchant of record, so it collects sales tax and VAT and pays them for you. Its fees page says the platform fee already covers card processing. On that $20 ebook sold to a US buyer you'd pay $1.50 in total, against $3.38 on Gumroad.

Read the extras before you move. The same page adds 1.5% for buyers outside the US, 1.5% for PayPal payments and 0.5% for subscription payments. Payouts to bank accounts outside the US cost 1%.

It's built with software sellers in mind. Licence keys are issued automatically after each sale, and you can deactivate or re-issue them. Download links are signed. There's one thing to weigh up, though. Stripe bought the company in 2024, and in a January 2026 post its CEO admitted to slower support and fewer product updates while the team builds Stripe Managed Payments. He said Lemon Squeezy users will get a way to migrate to it. No date was given.

Pros

  • Card processing is inside the 5% plus $0.50
  • Sales tax and VAT are collected and paid for you
  • Automatic licence keys for apps and plugins

Cons

  • Surcharges for non-US buyers, PayPal and subscriptions
  • The company itself says updates and support have slowed
  • A move to Stripe Managed Payments is planned, with no date
Visit Site

Sellfy

Sellfy plans and pricing page with Starter, Business and Premium on yearly billing

Sellfy turns the model around. There's no cut of each sale at all, and you pay a subscription instead. Starter is $29 a month, or $22 a month if you pay for a year up front. That's $264 a year, which is less than Gumroad takes from 110 sales of a $20 product.

Each plan has a sales ceiling. Starter covers up to $10,000 in sales a year, Business covers $50,000 for $79 a month, and Premium covers $200,000 for $159 a month. Go past your ceiling without upgrading and Sellfy says it may charge a 2% overage fee on the extra revenue. Seasonal sellers should do the sums, because the bill arrives in quiet months too.

All plans let you connect your own domain and sell downloads, subscriptions and print-on-demand merch from one store. Files can be up to 10 GB on Starter. The plan table lists VAT and tax settings, but nothing on the page says Sellfy files tax for you. There's a 14-day free trial.

Pros

  • 0% transaction fee on every plan
  • Own domain and a full storefront from the cheapest plan
  • Large files, up to 10 GB on Starter

Cons

  • No free plan after the trial
  • Annual sales caps push you up a plan as you grow
  • You handle your own tax returns
Visit Site

WordPress plugins

Easy Digital Downloads plugin page in the WordPress.org plugin directory

If you already run a WordPress site, you can add a download store to it for free. The plugin most people reach for is Easy Digital Downloads. Its free version on WordPress.org has more than 40,000 active installs and a 4.7 rating from 591 reviews, and it was last updated on 6 October 2026. It adds products, a cart, a checkout and file delivery to whatever theme you use now.

Free has a condition. The plugin's Stripe documentation says a 3% fee is added to Stripe payments unless you hold one of its paid yearly passes, and that the same 3% applies to PayPal for users of the free version. You also do the work a platform does for you. That means hosting, backups, plugin updates and your own tax returns.

We've already compared this plugin with SureCart and WooCommerce, with year-one and year-two costs, in our guide to running a WordPress shop without WooCommerce. Read that before you choose between them.

Pros

  • Free to install on a site you already own
  • Works with your current theme
  • Customers and orders stay in your own database

Cons

  • 3% on Stripe and PayPal sales with the free version
  • The store looks only as good as your theme makes it
  • Hosting, updates and tax are your job
View Plugin

PremiumPress (ours)

Inkwell illustration store design from the PremiumPress Digital Download theme demo

We make this one, so weigh what follows with that in mind. Our Digital Download theme is a WordPress theme with the store inside it. The cart, checkout, coupons, tax rates and buyer accounts are part of the theme, so there's no shop plugin to add. It costs $99 once for every site you own. We take nothing from your sales.

We checked how files are delivered in the released 12.0.89 build. Each upload is stored under a random name in a protected folder that blocks direct web access. A buyer gets a signed link that lasts five minutes and is tied to their account, and the theme checks they own the product before it sends the file. Bought files stay in a Downloads library in their account for later. A product can hold several files, such as an EPUB and a PDF, and the upload limit is 2 GB by default. Guest checkout is on by default and creates the buyer's account from a name and email as they pay.

Now the limits. The theme doesn't issue licence keys. Plans carry Free, Regular or Extended licence terms, and there's no activation system behind them, so a plugin or app seller who needs keys should look at Lemon Squeezy or Payhip. Payments run through separate gateway plugins such as Stripe and PayPal, connected to your own accounts. The theme alone ships with a test gateway only. You set a tax rate per country, but you file the returns. On nginx hosting the protected folder needs one deny rule added by hand. It's a single-seller store as well, with no payouts to other creators.

And you leave Gumroad's world behind. There's no Discover marketplace sending strangers to your page, nobody filing VAT for you, and no support team handling chargebacks. Hosting is an extra cost. Updates are included for six months, then cost $49 per six months if you want them, and there's a 14-day refund.

Pros

  • $99 once, with no percentage taken by us
  • Files kept in a protected folder and sent through expiring links
  • Store, checkout and buyer accounts on your own domain

Cons

  • No licence keys for software
  • You file your own sales tax and VAT
  • No built-in audience, and hosting is on you
Visit Theme Page

Stick with Gumroad?

Plenty of sellers should. Gumroad has been the merchant of record since 1 January 2025, which means it collects and pays sales tax worldwide and you have no tax settings to manage. If you sell a few hundred dollars a month to buyers in twenty countries, that service alone can be worth the 10%.

There's no monthly bill either. A product that sells twice a year costs you nothing in the months between. Discover does bring some sellers buyers they'd never have reached, even at 30%. And the fee drops on its own for big months. Once paid sales pass $20,000 in a calendar month, new direct sales that month are charged 5% plus $0.50.

Gumroad also has licence keys with multi-seat options, and you can point your own domain at your profile. Its rules do bar adult content. If neither that nor the fee bothers you, moving is work for little gain.

Final thoughts

If you're testing a first product, go with Payhip's free plan. The fee is half of Gumroad's, EU and UK VAT is filed for you, and you can leave without having paid a subscription.

Selling an app, a plugin or anything that needs activation? Lemon Squeezy has the best key handling here and takes tax off your hands. Just read its January 2026 update first, and be ready for a migration to Stripe's product at some point.

Sellfy makes sense once sales are regular. At $264 a year for up to $10,000 in sales, it beats any percentage fee quickly. It makes less sense if you sell in bursts.

The two WordPress routes suit people who want the customer list, the design and the checkout on their own domain, and who don't mind looking after a site. The free plugin fits a site you already have. Our theme fits a new store where you'd like the shop and the design in one purchase, as long as you can live without licence keys and will do your own tax.

FAQ

How much does Gumroad take from each sale in 2026?
Its pricing page says 10% plus $0.50 on sales through your profile or direct links, and 30% on sales that come through the Discover marketplace. The help centre says card processing of 2.9% plus $0.30 is added to the 10% rate. The 30% rate includes processing.
Which Gumroad alternative is free to start?
Payhip's Free Forever plan has no monthly cost and a 5% transaction fee. Lemon Squeezy has no monthly fee and charges 5% plus $0.50. The free version of Easy Digital Downloads costs nothing to install on WordPress but adds 3% to Stripe and PayPal sales.
Is there an alternative with no transaction fee at all?
Sellfy charges 0% on all plans and bills a subscription from $22 a month on yearly billing. Payhip's Pro plan is $99 a month with no fee. Our Digital Download theme is $99 once and we take no cut. Stripe or PayPal still charge for processing in each case.
Who deals with VAT if I leave Gumroad?
Lemon Squeezy is a merchant of record and handles sales tax and VAT for you. Payhip says it collects and remits EU and UK VAT and acts as a marketplace facilitator in the US and Canada. On Sellfy, a WordPress plugin or our theme, you set the rates and file the returns yourself.
Can I sell software licence keys without Gumroad?
Yes. Lemon Squeezy issues keys automatically after each sale, and Payhip can generate keys or use a list you upload. Our Digital Download theme doesn't issue licence keys, so it suits files that don't need activation.
Will I lose my customers if I move away from Gumroad?
Your Gumroad buyers don't move with you. Gumroad's help centre says you can export a CSV of your sales, so save that before you switch. Check that privacy law in your buyers' countries lets you email them from a new store.
Can I use my own domain with these platforms?
Payhip, Lemon Squeezy and Sellfy all say you can connect a custom domain. Gumroad supports one too. A WordPress store is on your own domain from the start.
How does a self-hosted store stop people sharing download links?
In our theme the file sits in a protected folder under a random name. Buyers get a signed link that expires after five minutes and only works for the account that bought it. A buyer can still pass on the file itself, which is true on every platform.
Is Lemon Squeezy shutting down?
Its site was live and taking sign-ups on 10 October 2026. Stripe owns it, and a January 2026 post from its CEO said users will be offered a way to migrate to Stripe Managed Payments. He gave no date.
At what sales level does a flat fee beat Gumroad?
On $20 products, Gumroad's own fee is $2.50 a sale. Sellfy's Starter plan at $264 a year is cheaper after 106 sales. Our theme at $99 is cheaper after 40 sales, before hosting.

Sources

Checked on 10 October 2026.

Related Posts

Etsy Alternatives for Sellers: 6 Places to Sell Handmade and Vintage in 2026
Nov 18, 2026

Etsy Alternatives for Sellers: 6 Places to Sell Handmade and Vintage in 2026

Six Etsy alternatives for handmade and vintage sellers, with every fee read on 10 October 2026: Amazon Handmade, eBay, Big Cartel, Shopify and WordPress.

Read more →
Ecommerce Website Examples: Seven Small Online Stores From Product Page to Checkout (2026)
Nov 14, 2026

Ecommerce Website Examples: Seven Small Online Stores From Product Page to Checkout (2026)

Seven real independent online stores, from British beans to digital brushes: product pages, checkout steps, delivery and returns, and how to build one.

Read more →
Skool Alternatives in 2026: Six Options Compared on Fees, Ownership and Courses
Nov 11, 2026

Skool Alternatives in 2026: Six Options Compared on Fees, Ownership and Courses

Six Skool alternatives with prices and fees read on each pricing page: Circle, Mighty Networks, Heartbeat, Discord, Discourse and a WordPress course theme.

Read more →
WordPress Website Examples: A Shop, a Job Board, a Car Auction and NASA (2026)
Nov 7, 2026

WordPress Website Examples: A Shop, a Job Board, a Car Auction and NASA (2026)

Seven real sites confirmed on WordPress from their own source code, from Nalgene's shop to a car auction, with what each charges and how to build one.

Read more →
Affiliate Website Examples: 7 Live Sites and Where Each One Puts Its Links
Nov 4, 2026

Affiliate Website Examples: 7 Live Sites and Where Each One Puts Its Links

Seven live affiliate sites, from a coupon site to a coffee blog. Where each puts its links, what its disclosure says, and how to build your own.

Read more →
Real Estate Website Examples From Agents, Portals and Builders (2026)
Oct 31, 2026

Real Estate Website Examples From Agents, Portals and Builders (2026)

Seven live property sites, from an Austin agent to an Aberdeen portal and a UK housebuilder, with their search, listing pages and what they charge.

Read more →