Etsy Alternatives for Sellers: 6 Places to Sell Handmade and Vintage in 2026
By Mark Fail ·

Etsy's fee policy was last updated on 5 October 2026, and the numbers in it explain why sellers keep looking around. A listing costs $0.20 and runs out after four months. When the item sells, Etsy takes 6.5% of the price plus whatever you charged for delivery and gift wrap. A US seller then pays 3% plus $0.25 to have the payment processed. On a $40 mug with $5 postage, that's $4.73 gone before tax.
Offsite Ads can more than double it. If a buyer clicks one of Etsy's ads on Google or a social network and orders from your shop within 30 days, Etsy charges another 15% of the order. Shops that have sold $10,000 in a year pay 12% and can never opt out again. The same mug now costs $11.48 to sell.
We opened and checked six other ways to sell on 10 October 2026, and each fee below was read on that company's own page. Two are marketplaces with their own shoppers. Four are shops you run yourself, and one of those is our Shop theme.
At a glance
| Option | Fixed cost | Fee per sale | Own domain | Brings buyers | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Etsy (for reference) | $0.20 per listing | 6.5% + 3% + $0.25 | No | Yes | - |
| Amazon Handmade | $39.99 once | 15%, minimum $0.30 | No | Yes | Makers who want reach |
| eBay | 250 free listings a month | 13.6% + $0.40 | No | Yes | Vintage and one-offs |
| Big Cartel | Free, $15 or $30 a month | None listed | From $15 plan | No | A first small shop |
| Shopify | From £19 a month | Card rate from 2% + 25p | Yes | No | A growing catalogue |
| WooCommerce | Free plugin, plus hosting | Card processor only | Yes | No | Full control |
| PremiumPress Shop | $99 one-time, plus hosting | Card processor only | Yes | No | One maker's own shop |
Amazon Handmade

Handmade is a section inside Amazon that only approved makers can list in. You open a Professional seller account, then apply by describing yourself, your products and how you make them. Amazon's page says goods have to be hand-altered, hand-designed, handcrafted, repurposed or upcycled. Plain vintage resale doesn't fit that list.
The fee is one number. Amazon deducts a referral fee of 15% or $0.30 on every unit shipped, whichever is greater, and its page says you only pay referral fees when you make a sale. The Professional plan normally costs $39.99 a month. Approved Handmade sellers pay that once, for the first month, and the page says the ongoing fee is then waived, which it puts at a saving of $480 a year.
So the cut is more than double Etsy's 6.5%, and there are no listing fees or renewals. The trade is Amazon's audience against Amazon's rules. Your products sit on Amazon's pages, under its search and its returns process, and you won't get a web address of your own.
Pros
- Shoppers are already on Amazon
- No listing fee and nothing to renew
- Monthly plan fee waived after the first month
Cons
- 15% of every sale
- An application before you can list
- Not open to ordinary vintage stock
eBay

Vintage sellers have the most to gain here. eBay has no handmade rule and no age rule, and buyers arrive searching for a maker's mark, an era or a pattern name. The Vintage and Antique Jewellery category on eBay UK showed 3,406,010 results when we opened it, with filters for metal, main stone, type, era, brand and condition.
Listing is cheap. eBay's US fee page gives every seller up to 250 listings a month with no insertion fee, then charges $0.35 each. The selling fee is higher than Etsy's. In most categories eBay keeps 13.6% of the total sale up to $7,500 per item, plus $0.40 per order, or $0.30 when the order is $10 or less. Jewellery is 15% on sales up to $5,000. Run the $45 mug order through the standard rate and eBay's share is $6.52.
Payment processing is inside that figure, so there's no second percentage to add.
Three of the first four items in our screenshot were marked Sponsored. Expect to compete with paid placements, and with factory-made goods in the same search results.
Pros
- Huge demand for vintage, antiques and collectables
- 250 listings a month before any insertion fee
- One selling fee with processing included
Cons
- 13.6% to 15% is a bigger cut than Etsy's
- Handmade work is shown beside mass-produced items
- Sponsored listings sit above ordinary results
Big Cartel

Big Cartel is a hosted shop builder aimed at artists and small makers. It isn't a marketplace. Nobody browses Big Cartel looking for candles, so every visitor comes from your own Instagram, email list or market stall.
What you get in return is a price that doesn't move with your sales. The free Gold plan gives you 5 product listings and one template, called Cosmos, with no card needed to sign up. Platinum is $15 a month after a seven-day trial and adds support for a custom domain, digital products, shipping labels and control over the shop's design. Diamond costs $30 a month and brings abandoned cart recovery and scheduled product drops.
We found no listing fee and no percentage of sales on the pricing page. Whoever processes the card still takes their own charge. The feature table also lists importing products from Etsy, which saves retyping a catalogue.
Pros
- A free plan to test with five products
- Flat monthly price, no cut of sales listed
- Imports products from Etsy
Cons
- No shoppers of its own
- Custom domains start on the $15 plan
- The free plan has one template
Shopify

Shopify is the larger hosted option. It suits a seller whose Etsy shop has outgrown a hobby, with dozens of products, repeat customers and plans to sell at fairs as well as online. Every plan includes unlimited products, inventory tracking and in-person selling.
Shopify showed us its UK prices, so these are in pounds. Basic is £25 a month, or £19 a month when you pay for a year. Card rates on Basic start from 2% plus 25p. If you use an outside payment provider, Shopify adds a 2% fee of its own. The banner offered three days free and then £1 a month for three months. Prices differ by country, so check the page from where you live.
A shop taking £1,000 a month in £25 orders would pay about £30 in card fees and £25 for the plan. That's 5.5% of sales. The bill is the same £25 in a month when nothing sells, though, and Etsy never charges you for a quiet January beyond the 20 cent listings.
Pros
- Unlimited products on every plan
- Online and in-person sales in one account
- Your own domain and customer list
Cons
- A monthly bill whether you sell or not
- 2% extra with an outside payment provider on Basic
- You bring every visitor yourself
WooCommerce

WooCommerce is the free shop plugin for WordPress. WordPress.org lists it at more than 7 million active installs, with a 4.5 star rating from 4,825 reviews. Version 11.2.1 came out on 9 October 2026, the day before we checked.
The plugin charges no listing fee and no commission. Your costs are hosting, a domain name and the card processor's rate. You also pick a theme and usually a payment extension, then keep all of it updated yourself. Nobody else can raise your fees or close your shop, and nobody else will fix it on a Sunday night either.
This route asks the most of you. A maker who is comfortable in WordPress admin will be fine. One who has never installed a plugin should budget a few weekends, or pay someone. We compared it with lighter setups in running a WordPress shop without WooCommerce.
Pros
- Free, with no cut of sales
- The biggest choice of themes and extensions
- You own the site and the customer data
Cons
- Hosting, updates and security are your job
- Several parts to choose and connect
- No built-in audience
PremiumPress (ours)

We make this one, so read it with that in mind. The Shop theme is a WordPress theme with the cart and checkout built into it, and it runs without WooCommerce. It's a shop for one seller. You list your own products and nobody else sells on it.
Everything here was read from the released 12.0.89 build. Products take a price, a "was" price, a SKU and a stock count, and options such as size and colour combine into variants with their own price and stock. Shipping can be a flat rate, a rate per country, weight bands, or free above an order value you set. Buyers can check out as guests. There are coupon codes with a use limit, star reviews on product pages, and an order page that moves through ordered, packed, shipped and delivered with a carrier and tracking number. Of the 57 homepage designs, three are filed under handmade and craft stores. The screenshot shows one of them, Linden.
For someone leaving Etsy, the import screen matters most. It recognises Etsy's listings CSV and brings in each title, description, price, quantity, set of tags and the first photo.
That import won't carry your variations, your reviews or the other photos. Stripe and PayPal connect through separate plugins. Tax is a rate you enter per country, so the US sales tax that Etsy collects for you becomes your paperwork. You need hosting and a domain. And there's no audience. A new shop on your own domain starts with zero visitors, and no theme changes that. The licence is $99 once for every site you own, with six months of updates, then $49 per six months if you want more, and a 14-day refund.
Pros
- One payment, no monthly fee and no cut of sales
- Cart, checkout, shipping and coupons in the theme
- Reads an Etsy listings CSV
Cons
- No marketplace traffic at all
- The Etsy import skips variations, reviews and extra photos
- You handle tax, hosting and payment plugins
Stick with Etsy?
For plenty of shops, yes. Etsy's buyers arrive already wanting something handmade or old, and none of the four self-run options above can offer that on day one. Its 6.5% is also the lowest marketplace cut on this page. Amazon Handmade takes 15% and eBay 13.6%.
Etsy does the dull jobs too. The fee policy says it calculates, collects and remits sales tax on orders sent to US buyers. And a shop under $10,000 a year can opt out of Offsite Ads, which removes the 15% charge that causes most of the anger.
If you add your own site, keep the two apart. The same policy says any action to move a transaction off Etsy is strictly prohibited, so don't message Etsy buyers a link to your new shop. Build the second audience somewhere else.
Final thoughts
If your problem is reach, pick another marketplace. Makers should apply to Amazon Handmade and accept the 15%. Vintage and collectable sellers will do better on eBay, where 250 listings a month cost nothing to post.
If your problem is fees or control, you need your own shop, and the question becomes how much setup you can face. Big Cartel is the gentlest start. Five products on the free plan is enough to learn whether your followers will buy away from Etsy at all. Shopify makes sense once monthly sales comfortably cover £25 and you want stock, fairs and online orders in one account.
The two WordPress routes cost the least over several years and ask the most of you at the start. WooCommerce gives the widest choice of add-ons. Our Shop theme is quicker to set up because the shop parts are already in it, and it's a one-time $99.
FAQ
Sources
- Etsy: Fees and Payments Policy, last updated 5 October 2026, for listing, transaction, Offsite Ads, Pattern and sales tax terms.
- Etsy: Etsy Payments Policy, last updated 31 July 2026, for payment processing fees by country.
- WordPress.org: WooCommerce, with installs, rating and version from the WordPress.org plugins API.
- PremiumPress Shop Theme. Features are described from the released 12.0.89 build.
Checked on 10 October 2026.





