Membership in Responsive Theme

I created memberships in the Directorypress Responsive theme and set them to use the listing I set up called “Sponsors Listing.” The listing is different from the rest and it only applies to those who join a membership so I set it the Sponsors Listing under “Which Package” option. However, when I tested this, it directly went to one of the other listings, not the one I specified. Can anyone help me with this?