Payments Are Not Going Through As Recurring

I have a problem when not all of the payments for a listing are marked as “Recurring” by PayPal.
The user has to pay every single month and they complain about it (naturally).

See attached. Some listings were paid for as a regular purchase and some were paid as recurring even though my settings say recurring in the Admin area.

Is there a fix for this? A setting I’m missing? Something I’m overlooking?